Check out the awesome comic books in the Goldin Pop Culture Elite Auction March 2024!

Value of Atlas Mystic Comics

Mystic Comics Price Guide

Some of the coolest old Atlas Comics are in the Mystic title. These gory and violent horror comic books are super-cool, and very collectible today.

The series was first published as a superhero series during the war by Timely Comics. For simplicity, we have included all the early superhero books here as well.

If you've found old comic books, then we appraise them for FREE. We also offer cash for comic book collections and single items. Click the button below and send us your list.

Click Here to Get Your Free Appraisal or Consign Your Books to Auction!

Mystic Comics Volume One: 1940-42

Mystic Comics v1 #1

Record Sale: $25,440
Minimum Value: $200

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic Comics v1 #2

Record Sale: $30,030
Minimum Value: $260

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic Comics v1 #3

Record Sale: $21,800
Minimum Value: $70

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic Comics v1 #4

Record Sale: $6,600

Minimum Value: $100

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic Comics v1 #5

Record Sale: $16,200
Minimum Value: $200

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic Comics v1 #6

Record Sale: $12,400
Minimum Value: $200

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic Comics v1 #7

Record Sale: $12,100
Minimum Value: $200

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic Comics v1 #8

Record Sale: $21,080
Minimum Value: $500

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic Comics v1 #9

Record Sale: $19,200
Minimum Value: $500

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic Comics v1 #10

Record Sale: $5,060
Minimum Value: $100

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic Comics Volume Two: 1944-45

Mystic Comics v2 #1

Record Sale: $9,700
Minimum Value: $120

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic Comics v2 #3: Click Here for Values

Mystic Comics v2 #2

Record Sale: $4,560
Minimum Value: $100

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic Comics v2 #3

Record Sale: $2,530
Minimum Value: $60

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic Comics v2 #4

Record Sale: $4,800
Minimum Value: $150

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic Price Guide: Volume Three, Atlas Comics Horror-Suspense

Mystic #1

Record Sale: $2,500
Minimum Value: $50

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #2

Record Sale: $510
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #3

Record Sale: $1,210
Minimum Value: $50

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic Comics #4

Record Sale: $1,050
Minimum Value: $50

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #5

Record Sale: $2,300
Minimum Value: $50

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #6

Record Sale: $550
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #7

Record Sale: $580
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #8

Record Sale: $1,200
Minimum Value: $50

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #9

Record Sale: $1,440
Minimum Value: $50

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #10

Record Sale: $890
Minimum Value: $40

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic Comics #11

Record Sale: $280
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #12

Record Sale: $150
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #13

Record Sale: $660
Minimum Value: $40

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #14

Record Sale: $1,230
Minimum Value: $30

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #15

Record Sale: $570
Minimum Value: $40

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #16

Record Sale: $1,560
Minimum Value: $30

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic Comics #17

Record Sale: $800
Minimum Value: $50

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #18

Record Sale: $3,840
Minimum Value: $40

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #19

Record Sale: $1,000
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #20

Record Sale: $1,020
Minimum Value: $30

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #21

Record Sale: $950
Minimum Value: $60

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #22

Record Sale: $500
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #23

Record Sale: $750
Minimum Value: $30

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #24

Record Sale: $1,240
Minimum Value: $40

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic Comics #25

Record Sale: $780
Minimum Value: $40

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #26

Record Sale: $600
Minimum Value: $60

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #27

Record Sale: $280
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #28

Record Sale: $3,840
Minimum Value: $70

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #29

Record Sale: $650
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #30

Record Sale: $660
Minimum Value: $40

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #31

Record Sale: $160
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #32

Record Sale: $900
Minimum Value: $60

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #33

Record Sale: $230
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #34

Record Sale: $500
Minimum Value: $30

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #35

Record Sale: $600
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #36

Record Sale: $400

Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #37

Record Sale: $780
Minimum Value: $30

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #38

Record Sale: $550
Minimum Value: $60

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #39

Record Sale: $120
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #40

Record Sale: $160
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #41

Record Sale: $330
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #42

Record Sale: $80
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #43

Record Sale: $120
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #44

Record Sale: $110
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #45

Record Sale: $390
Minimum Value: $30

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #46

Record Sale: $80
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #47

Record Sale: $350
Minimum Value: $30

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #48

Record Sale: $180
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #49

Record Sale: $110
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #50

Record Sale: $130
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #51

Record Sale: $180
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #52

Record Sale: $1,140
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #53

Record Sale: $300
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #54

Record Sale: $530
Minimum Value: $30

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #55

Record Sale: $720
Minimum Value: $40

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #56

Record Sale: $380
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #57

Record Sale: $1,250
Minimum Value: $30

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #58

Record Sale: $350
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #59

Record Sale: $400
Minimum Value: $30

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #60

Record Sale: $350
Minimum Value: $60

Have Yours Appraised

Mystic #61

Record Sale: $190
Minimum Value: $25

Have Yours Appraised

History of Mystic Comics

Mystic Comics was a three-volume series published Atlas Comics, formerly known as Timely Comics and what would eventually evolve to be Marvel Comics.

The first two volumes in the series were superhero anthologies, which saw the return of Timely sensation the Human Torch. Created in what is referred to as the Golden Age of comics, Mystic Comics was made throughout the wars years, running from 1940-45.

The third volume of Mystic Comics were simply titled Mystic; they were horror-suspense stories, which had a total run of 61 issues from 1951-1957.

Although the third series had no superhero, it did feature the introductions of Blazing Skull, Black Widow and Destroyer. Bill Everett and John Severin were among the contributors to the series.