Check out the awesome comic books in the Goldin Pop Culture Elite Auction March 2024!

Mister Mystery Comics Price Guide

Value of Mister Mystery Comics

This is a classic Golden Age pre-Code horror series!

Pretty girls in trouble -- and often, literally, tied up -- with undead and macabre characters were the order of the day for early 1950s horror books.

Obscure publisher Stanley Morse was responsible for a couple of dozen comics, including long-forgotten titles like Flying Aces, Diary Confessions and Western Rough Riders.

But their horror titles, including Weird Chills and Weird Tales of the Future, include some of the must-own best horror comics for collectors.

Until the Comics Code Authority ruined it for everybody...

Here are record sales and minimum values for the entire Mister Mystery series.

To have your superhero, crime, romance, cartoon or horror comic books appraised FREE by us, simply click the button below to begin.

Value of Mister Mystery Comics 1951-1954

Mister Mystery Comics #1

Record Sale: $2,270
Minimum Value: $40

Have Yours Appraised

Mister Mystery #2

Record Sale: $1,190
Minimum Value: $50

 Have Yours Appraised

Mister Mystery #3

Record Sale: $510
Minimum Value: $20

Have Yours Appraised

Mister Mystery #4
Bondage cover

Record Sale: $1,375
Minimum Value: $45

Have Yours Appraised

Mister Mystery #5

Record Sale: $2,600
Minimum Value: $70

Have Yours Appraised

Mister Mystery #6
Classic Bondage cover

Record Sale: $4,080
Minimum Value: $55

Have Yours Appraised

Mister Mystery #7
Bondage cover

Record Sale: $2,750
Minimum Value: $50

Have Yours Appraised

Mister Mystery #8

Record Sale: $1,560
Minimum Value: $30

Have Yours Appraised

(Article continues below)

All Our Horror Comics Price Guides

Mister Mystery #9

Record Sale: $1,920
Minimum Value: $45

 Have Yours Appraised

Mister Mystery #10

Record Sale: $780
Minimum Value: $50

 Have Yours Appraised

Mister Mystery #11
Ant torture cover!

Record Sale: $9,865
Minimum Value: $60

Have Yours Appraised

Mister Mystery #12
Classic Injury to eye cover!

Record Sale: $7,250
Minimum Value: $200

 Have Yours Appraised

Mister Mystery #13

Record Sale: $3,050
Minimum Value: $55

 Have Yours Appraised

Mister Mystery #14

Record Sale: $630
Minimum Value: $55

 Have Yours Appraised

Mister Mystery #15

Record Sale: $575
Minimum Value: $30

Have Yours Appraised

Mister Mystery #16
Classic Bondage cover

Record Sale: $1,560
Minimum Value: $50

 Have Yours Appraised

Mister Mystery #17

Record Sale: $1,425
Minimum Value: $85

 Have Yours Appraised

Mister Mystery Comics #18
Headhunter cover

Record Sale: $2,600
Minimum Value: $120

Have Yours Appraised

Mister Mystery #19
Final issue

Record Sale: $430
Minimum Value: $50

Have Yours Appraised

Sell Your Horror Comic Books to Us!

If you have old horror, crime, superhero or other comic books from the 1930s-1980s, then request a free appraisal or offer.

Simply click the button below to begin.

More of our Comic Price Guides

Mister Mystery Comics and Other Horror Comic Books
See values of all the classic Horror comics, including EC Comics titles and gory issues.

Read More >

Best Horror Comics With Gross Covers!
Some of the most valuable Horror comics have lurid, disgusting images on their covers. See the best here!

Read More >

EC Comics Price Guide
The master of pre-Code Horror books was EC. See what their original series are worth today.

Read More >

Most Expensive Comic Books of All Time
See what the world record most valuable comic books are and what they sold for!

Read More >

Sell Pre-Code Horror Comics to Sell My Comic Books for Immediate Cash!

The 100 Hottest Comics of 2024. Click to Explore!