Top 60 Best Horror Comic Books
60 Most Expensive Horror Comic Books
Ready for some scarily high prices on horror comics? Here are the top 60 all-time highest sales. Click on any image or link to see current item prices.
See also: Grossest Horror Comics | EC Comics Price Guide
60 All-Time Highest "Gross-ing" Horror Comic Books
1. Suspense Comics #3
Highly controversial cover with Nazis,
sacrifice and Klan images
Record sale: $173,000
Minimum value: $3,000
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
2. Prize Comics #7
1st Horror Comic Book ever published
Record sale: $35,000
Minimum value: $750
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
NEW ENTRY! Punch Comics #12 (1945):
Shootout in Giant Skull Cover
Record sale: $31,000
Minimum value: $800
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
3. Vault of Horror #12
Classic Torture and Bondage cover
Record sale: $29,000
Minimum value: $200
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
4. Weird Mysteries #5
Brain Removed from Head cover
Record sale: $18,000
Minimum value: $200
5. Werewolf by Night #32
1st Appearance of Moon Knight
Record sale: $14,500
Minimum value: $30
EWWW! GALLERY OF THE GROSSEST HORROR COMICS! >>>
If your stomach can stand it... We've put together a Gallery of the Gross: simply the best horror comics covers ever published. Be warned: not for the faint-hearted >>>
6. Captain America Comics #74 (1949):
Rare Captain America horror
comic, retitled to
"Captain America's Weird Tales"
in an attempt to revive sales
Record sale: $14,400
Minimum value: $500
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
7. House of Secrets #92 (1970):
1st Swamp Thing
Established Bernie Wrightson in
horror comics
Record sale: $14,000
Minimum value: $50
8. Tales to Astonish #1 (1959):
Classic Marvel horror, 1st in series
Record sale: $13,100
Minimum value: $150
9. Haunt of Fear #15 (1950):
First issue of the series (continued from “Gunfighter”);
Classic Graham Ingels artwork
Record sale: $13,000
Minimum value: $150
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
NEW ENTRY! Famous Monsters of Filmland #1 (1958):
First issue of the series of
magazine-sized horror comics
Record sale: $12,500
Minimum value: $100
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
10. Vampirella #1 (1969):
Origin and 1st Appearance of
Vampirella in Horror Comic Books
Record sale: $13,000
Minimum value: $50
NEW ENTRY! Walking Dead #1 (2003):
First issue of the series of
modern horror comic books;
TV show drives values
Record sale: $11,000
Minimum value: $200
11. Haunt of Fear #17 (1950):
Origin stories for Crypt of Terror,
Vault of Horror, and Haunt of Fear;
Classic Graham Ingels artwork
Record sale: $10,200
Minimum value: $200
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
12. Weird Tales of the Future #3 (1952):
Classic Cover art
Record sale: $9,500
Minimum value: $300
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
13. Eerie #1 (1947):
Rare Avon Per One-Shot;
Publisher revived Horror Comic
Books series in 1951
Record sale: $9,500
Minimum value: $400
14. Crime SuspenStories #22 (1954):
Classic Severed Head cover
Record sale: $9,500
Minimum value: $200
15. Crypt of Terror #17 (1950):
First issue of the series that later became "Tales from the Crypt"
Record sale: $9,000
Minimum value: $75
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
16. Tomb of Terror #15 (1952):
Disgusting Exploding Face
Cover Art!
Record sale: $9,000
Minimum value: $75
17. Adventures in the Unknown #1 (1948): Earliest Ongoing Series of
Horror Comic Books
Record sale: $7,700
Minimum value: $50
NEW ENTRY! Spellbound #14 (1953):
Classic Cover with Man and Zombies in Romantic Park
Record sale: $8,300
Minimum value: $50
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
18. Crime Patrol #15 (1950):
1st Appearance of the Crypt-Keeper
Record sale: $7,500
Minimum value: $150
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
19. Mister Mystery #12 (1953):
Classic Flame Approaching
Eye Cover art
Record sale: $7,000
Minimum value: $50
20. Startling Terror Tales #11 (1952):
Classic L. B. Cole cover art
Record sale: $6,800
Minimum value: $50
21. Crime Patrol #16 (1950):
Last in series before renamed "Crypt of Terror"
Record sale: $6,600
Minimum value: $50
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
22. Black Cat Mystery #50 (1954):
Explicit Radium-Rotted Corpse cover
Record sale: $6,200
Minimum value: $100
23. Captain America Comics #75 (1950):
Rare Captain America horror comic,
retitled "Captain America's Weird Tales"; last Cap comic until 1954
Record sale: $5,900
Minimum value: $100
24. Haunt of Fear #16 (1950):
Origin and first appearance, Old Witch;
Classic Graham Ingels artwork
Record sale: $5,300
Minimum value: $25
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
25. Tales of Terror Annual #1 (1951):
Very rare Golden Age
horror comic -- only 13
CGC-graded copies!
Record sale: $5,100
Minimum value: $???
26. Moon Girl #5 (1948):
The first of EC's infamous
horror comic books
Record sale: $5,000
Minimum value: $100
27. Tales from the Crypt #20 (1950):
First issue of the series; retitled
from "Crypt of Terror"
Record sale: $5,000
Minimum value: $50
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
NEW ENTRY! Crime Does Not Pay #24 (1942):
Criminal Pushes Woman's Head on to Flaming Stove
Record sale: $4,800
Minimum value: $300
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
28. Tomb of Dracula #10 (1973):
First Appearance of
Blade the Vampire Slayer
Record sale: $4,300
Minimum value: $20
NEW ENTRY! Underworld Crime #7 (1953):
Woman Threatened by Hot Poker
Record sale: $4,300
Minimum value: $100
30. Fight Against Crime #20 (1954):
Decapitated Woman's Head Dumped in Sewer cover!
Record sale: $4,000
Minimum value: $200
29. Vampirella #113:
Last issue, very low print run
Record sale: $4,000
Minimum value: $50
NEW ENTRY! Marvel Preview #7 (1976):
1st Appearance Satana; 1st Rocket Raccoon
Record sale: $3,800
Minimum value: $100
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
31. Lawbreakers Suspense
Stories #11 (1953): Madman Holding Severed Tongues Cover!
Record sale: $3,300
Minimum value: $75
32. Chilling Tales #13 (1952):
First issue of series; Rare, only
17 CGC-rated copies
Record sale: $3,200
Minimum value: $100
33. Strange Tales #1 (1951):
Classic pre-hero Marvel Horror
Record sale: $3,000
Minimum value: $200
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
34. Creepy #1 (1964):
First issue of the magazine-sized
Horror comic books series
Record sale: $3,000
Minimum value: $10
35. Haunt of Fear #4 (1950):
First Appearance of Crypt Keeper
and Vault Keeper in this
Horror Comic series
Record sale: $2,900
Minimum value: $50
36. Journey into Mystery #1 (1951):
First issue of long-running Horror and Suspense series
Record sale: $2,900
Minimum value: $50
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
37. Venus #19 (1952):
Last issue of series, rare,
only 32 of these horror comic
books certified by CGC
Record sale: $2,900
Minimum value: $300
38. Witches' Tales #25 (1954):
Controversial Decapitated Head
as Bell Clapper cover!
Record sale: $2,500
Minimum value: $100
NEW ENTRY! Beware #10 (1954):
Zombies Drag Top-Heavy Woman into Grave
Record sale: $2,800
Minimum value: $100
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
39. Tales from the Crypt #33 (1952):
Origin of Crypt Keeper
Record sale: $2,400
Minimum value: $25
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
40. Crime SuspenStories #20 (1954):
Graphic and Controversial
Hanged Man Cover
Record sale: $2,400
Minimum value: $50
41. House of Mystery #1 (1952):
First issue of long-running
series of suspense and
horror comic books
Record sale: $2,300
Minimum value: $75
42. Black Magic #1 (1950):
First issue of series; Jack Kirby cover
Record sale: $2,200
Minimum value: $50
NEW ENTRY! Thing #7 (1953):
Vampire Gouging Out Eyes cover
Record sale: $2,100
Minimum value: $50
NEW ENTRY! Savage Tales #1 (1971):
First "graphic" Conan; published as magazine under
Curtis label to avoid Comics Code Authority
rules on horror comic books;
First Appearance of Man-Thing
Record sale: $1,800
Minimum value: $50
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
43. Tomb of Dracula #1 (1972):
1st in Series, Neal Adams cover
Record sale: $2,000
Minimum value: $5
44. Witching Hour #1 (1969):
1st in Series
Record sale: $1,700
Minimum value: $5
45. Amazing Mysteries #32 (1949):
1st Ever Marvel / Atlas Horror comic book
Record sale: $1,600
Minimum value: $50
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
46. Creatures on the Loose #10:
First issue of the horror
comic books series retitled from
"Tower of Shadows"
Record sale: $1,550
Minimum value: $5
48. Horrific #3 (1953):
Classic Bullethole in Forehead cover
Record sale: $1,500
Minimum value: $200
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
NEW ENTRY! Dracula Lives! #1 (1973):
Curtis magazine (Marvel): rare in high grade
Record sale: $1,200
Minimum value: $20
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
49. Classic Comics / Classics
Illustrated #13 (1943): Very early
horror comic book
Record sale: $1,400
Minimum value: $20
50. Worlds of Fear #10 (1953):
Classic Eye-Theme Cover
Record sale: $1,000
Minimum value: $75
51. Tales of Horror #1 (1952):
First issue in Golden Age horror
comic books series
Record sale: $900
Minimum value: $25
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
NEW ENTRY! Vampire Tales magazine #2 (1973):
Curtis (Marvel) publication, rare in high grade
Record sale: $820
Minimum value: $15
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
52. Fantastic Fears #5 (1964):
First Steve Ditko art
Record sale: $800
Minimum value: $25
53. Chamber of Chills #21 (1951):
First issue in this classic series
of horror comic books
Record sale: $770
Minimum value: $25
54. Tower of Shadows #1 (1969):
1st issue of classic Marvel
horror comic books series
Record sale: $770
Minimum value: $5
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
55. House of Secrets #1 (1956):
First issue of classic horror
comic books series
Record sale: $760
Minimum value: $20
56. Tales of Terror #1 (1952):
First in Golden Age Horror
comic books series
Record sale: $700
Minimum value: $25
57. Tales from the Tomb #1 (1969):
First in Series
Record sale: $650
Minimum value: $1
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
58. Chamber of Chills #23 (1954):
Classic horror comic books
cover, Woman kissing Zombie!
Record sale: $640
Minimum value: $100
59. Chamber of Darkness #1 (1969):
1st in this Silver Age horror
comic books series
Record sale: $570
Minimum value: $5
60. Eerie #2 (#1 in series) (1966):
First issue of Magazine horror
Record sale: $500
Minimum value: $5
Click to find values | Have yours appraised
EWWW! GALLERY OF THE GROSSEST HORROR COMICS! >>>
If your stomach can stand it... We've put together a Gallery of the Gross: simply the best horror comics covers ever published. Be warned: not for the faint-hearted >>>
Go from Best Horror Comic Books to the Comic Price Guide menu
Sell Horror Comics to Us! We Pay Immediate Cash for Comic Books
Recent Articles
-
Exciting Comics Price Guide
Jan 15, 19 09:44 AM
The Golden Age series which launched the career of the Black Terror. Find out the record sales and minimum values for Exciting Comics -- and have your comic books valued FREE by Sell My Comic Books!
-
Captain Midnight Comic Book Price Guide
Jan 13, 19 09:26 PM
Our price guide to Captain Midnight comics shows record sales and minimum values for this classic Golden Age series. Published from 1942 to 1948, it features some incredible art and stories, plus clas…
-
Blue Beetle Comics Price Guide
Jan 09, 19 09:31 AM
Find out the value of classic Blue Beetle comics, some of the most interesting and sexy comic books of the Golden Age. We publish record sales and minimum values. Have your comics appraised FREE or se…