NOTE: We use eBay to provide references to live prices of comic books. Clicking a text link or image marked ‘Check live prices’ will take you to eBay.

Value of Atlas Mystery Tales Comics

Mystery Tales Comics Price Guide

Before Marvel Comics, there was Atlas, and one of the tougher titles to collect is Mystery Tales.

If you've come across Atlas Comics, including these cool old horror stories, then we will appraise them for FREE. Simply click the button below to begin the valuation process. We also buy comics for cash.


Click Here to Get Your Free Appraisal!

Value of Mystery Tales Comics

Mystery Tales #1: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #1

Record Sale: $7,500
Minimum Value: $100

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #2: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #2

Record Sale: $4,240
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #3: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #3

Record Sale: $3,000
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #4: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #4

Record Sale: $5,200
Minimum Value: $40

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #5: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #5

Record Sale: $8,500
Minimum Value: $40

Check Live Prices | Have Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #6: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #6

Record Sale: $600
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #7: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #7

Record Sale: $5,000
Minimum Value: $60

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #8: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #8

Record Sale: $1,490
Minimum Value: $30

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #9: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #9

Record Sale: $6,060
Minimum Value: $40

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #10: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #10

Record Sale: $2,050
Minimum Value: $40

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #11: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #11

Record Sale: $3,100
Minimum Value: $40

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #12: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #12

Record Sale: $875
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #13: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #13

Record Sale: $780
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #14: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #14

Record Sale: $3,000
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #15: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #15

Record Sale: $1,600
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #16: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #16

Record Sale: $800
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live Prices | Have Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #17: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #17

Record Sale: $1,670
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #18: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #18

Record Sale: $930
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #19: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #19

Record Sale: $14,400
Minimum Value: $200

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #20: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #20

Record Sale: $380
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #21: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #21

Record Sale: $1,020
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #22: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #22

Record Sale: $1,020
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #23: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #23

Record Sale: $1,320
Minimum Value: $40

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #24: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #24

Record Sale: $340
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #25: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #25

Record Sale: $290
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #26: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales Comics #26

Record Sale: $1,160
Minimum Value: $50

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #27: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #27

Record Sale: $200
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live Prices | Have Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #28: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #28

Record Sale: $580
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #29: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #29

Record Sale: $730
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #30: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #30

Record Sale: $340
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #31: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #31

Record Sale: $280
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #32: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #32

Record Sale: $600
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #33: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #33

Record Sale: $150
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #34: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #34

Record Sale: $240
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #35: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #35

Record Sale: $750
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #36: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #36

Record Sale: $2,150
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #37: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #37

Record Sale: $530
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #38: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #38

Record Sale: $200
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live Prices | Have Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #39: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #39

Record Sale: $350
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #40: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #40

Record Sale: $1,830
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #41: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #41

Record Sale: $200
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #42: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #42

Record Sale: $310
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #43: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #43

Record Sale: $1,010
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #44: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #44

Record Sale: $600
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #45: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #45

Record Sale: $570
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #46: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales Comics #46

Record Sale: $260
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #47: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #47

Record Sale: $230
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #48: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #48

Record Sale: $470
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #49: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #49

Record Sale: $530
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live Prices | Have Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #50: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #50

Record Sale: $580
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #51: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #51

Record Sale: $910
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #52: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #52

Record Sale: $320
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #54: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales #54

Record Sale: $260
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

Mystery Tales #53: Click Here for Values

Mystery Tales Comics #53

Record Sale: $530
Minimum Value: $25

Check Live PricesHave Yours Appraised

All Our Horror Comics Price Guides

More of our Comic Price Guides

Other Atlas Comics in Mystery Tales Comics

Other Atlas Comics in Mystery Tales Comics
See prices for all the major Atlas titles, including pre-hero Tales of Suspense, Strange Tales and more.

Read More >

Best Horror Comics by Cover Art

Best Horror Comics by Cover Art
Gallery of the Gross! Some of the most gruesome pre-Code horror comic books ever published.

Read More >

Most Valuable Horror Comic Books

Most Valuable Horror Comic Books
The top 100 most expensive horror comics ever sold, with record prices.

Read More >

Rarest of the Rare Comic Books

Rarest of the Rare Comic Books
You'll go your whole life without seeing a single one of those super-rare issues.

Read More >

Sell My Comic Books Pays Immediate CASH For Mystery Tales Comics!